Opinions of Home Learning - UK Vs US

Today, the phrase 'Home Learning' refers to receivingCalifornia, they decided that the matter needed
one's education at home, either at lower, junior, orre-clarification.
secondary level; but also encompassing extra-curricularThat's not to say that the UK hasn't had similar efforts
learning and further education such as undergraduatemade to help prospective home-schooling parents to
and master's degrees. The reason for this broadwithdraw their kids from schools. In 2002 statutory
meaning now can be seen to have arisen, not onlyguidance was introduced to help them do just that.
because of the increased accessibility of homeHowever recently, another article concerning home
learning via online courses and e-Learning, but also dueteaching has appeared. Children and Young People
to the growing acceptance of a home education beingNow reports of a Lancashire investigation into a
as legitimate as a traditional school-based one.sudden rise of children being taught at home. The
However, between the UK and the US, opinions ofnumber has doubled to over 450 in eight years, but this
home learning can still be seen to vary.is a cause for concern for some because there is no
The last major national reflection of home schoolinglaw ensuring that teachers can observe whether
came just over a year ago when the BBC reported ofhome education matches that of traditional schools.
a "sharp increase" between 2005 and 2006. In anAside from the numbers themselves (there are nearly
article still available at bbc.co.uk it is stated, that in that2 million home taught children in the US), it is when one
one year alone, there was a 39 per cent increase ofnotes the religious and moral connection with
children being withdrawn from school and being taughthome-schooling that the major differences between
at home instead. What is interesting about the report isthe US and UK opinions are most prevalent. In the UK
that rather than view this as a positive thing at all, thispress, one rarely hears of the reason for
increase seems to be considered as much a negativehome-teaching being a moral or religious one, in fact it
by-product of what is wrong with the school-systemis usually considered a very liberal alternative. Yet
as opposed to an improving national standard ofstateside by 2007, religion was the primary reason for
home-schooling.children being withdrawn from school in 83 percent of
Interestingly, in the US, opinions tend to differ fromhome taught families. Yet, what perhaps is most
state to state. In an article earlier this month atimportant (aside from the discussion of whether the
onenewsnow.com, Pete Chagnon and Jody Brownchild should choose) is the academic quality of a home
report a new bill in the state of Idaho which will ensureeducation. In a report by the US National Centre for
that parents who choose to educate their children ateducation Statistics home taught children "typically
home 'are in compliance with the state's compulsoryscore 15 to 30 percentile points above public school
attendance law'. Up until this point Idaho law hasstudents on standardized academic achievement
considered home-schooling as "comparable instruction",tests". Therefore, it is seemingly hard to argue with the
but after the method of teaching was outlawedworth of a US home education, but in the UK we
completely in 2008 (for a brief time, at least) inremain unaware of its comparative academic worth.